How to benchmark a value proposition and find the deal breaker that was blocking the sale

    A two-sided marketplace couldn't close its first sale on the supply side. We compared its value proposition with competitors' point by point, for each side, classified each point as parity, superiority or inferiority and separated deal breakers from deal makers. A deal breaker was missing; the client started offering it and that unlocked the sale.

    Profile

    B2B2C marketplace · Pre-seed

    Problem

    One side of the marketplace already had traction, the other wasn't selling. The question was whether the problem was the value proposition or sales execution, and whether something the market considers mandatory was missing.

    Solution

    Map the value proposition of the main competitors, compare it with the client's on each point and identify what is a condition for entering the race and what makes you win.

    What we did

    • We built one spreadsheet per side of the marketplace, with value points in the rows, grouped into quality, liability, service and benefits, and the client and competitors in the columns.
    • We classified each point with a fixed rule: parity when the client matches the market, inferiority when the client doesn't have it and most competitors do, superiority when the client has it and almost no competitor does.
    • We separated deal breakers, what the buyer requires to even consider the offer, from deal makers, what makes them choose one supplier over another, and crossed both lists with what the client did and didn't have.

    Result

    The client could see its value proposition against the market, side by side, and the list of deal breakers it was missing. One of them was an insurance policy the market already offered: the client took it out and that made the sale possible.

    Key learnings

    • Before investing more in marketing or sales, make sure no deal breaker is missing. Without it, no campaign closes a deal.
    • Parity doesn't win the sale, but lacking it loses it. Superiority only counts if it's on a point the buyer values.
    • A marketplace has two value propositions. One side can be ahead while the other is stuck; compare each side separately.

    Do it yourself

    1. Build a simple spreadsheet: in the rows, 20 to 30 value points grouped by theme; in the columns, your company and 4 to 6 competitors, marking who has each point. Next to it, count how many competitors have each point and classify it: if you have it and almost no one else does, it's superiority; if you don't and most do, it's inferiority; otherwise, it's parity.

    2. To separate deal breakers from deal makers, use evidence from buyers and not just internal opinion: loss reasons in the CRM, interviews with people who bought and who didn't, public reviews of competitors and the questions that come up most in sales calls.

    3. Ask an LLM with web search, and check each point by hand:

      I'll list my company and [N] competitors in [category], with each one's website. For each side of the business ([side A] and [side B]), gather 20 to 30 value points that appear on the websites, pricing pages and public reviews, grouped by theme. Build a table of who has and who doesn't have each point and classify each one, for my company, as parity, superiority or inferiority. Then suggest which look like deal breakers and which look like deal makers, explain why, and tell me what evidence I should look for with buyers to confirm.